Skip to main content

Debate on new provinces continues with varied political viewpoints

Animated editorial illustration for: Debate on new provinces continues with varied political viewpoints
0:000:00
AI-assisted editorial illustration — not a photograph.

At a glance

  • A national debate is ongoing about creating new provinces in Pakistan.
  • Proposals include the formation of Bahawalpur, South Punjab, and Hazara.
  • Sindh CM Murad Ali Shah has firmly rejected any proposal to divide Sindh.

Story so far

A national debate is underway in Pakistan regarding the creation of new provinces, with proponents arguing the current four are insufficient for the country's large population. Former minister Muhammad Ali Durrani has proposed creating Bahawalpur, South Punjab, and Hazara provinces. However, the proposal faces strong opposition, particularly regarding the division of Sindh, which Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah has firmly rejected. The matter is expected to be debated in parliament.

Latest development

Political leader Fawad Chaudhry has weighed in on the national debate, questioning if dividing provinces like Sindh and Punjab is the only solution and raising the idea of a 'new system'.

Latest updates

Adding a new dimension to the national conversation, political leader Fawad Chaudhry has weighed in on the debate surrounding the creation of new provinces. In recent comments, he questioned whether dividing existing provinces like Sindh and Punjab is the only solution, suggesting the possibility of a “new system” as an alternative.

In a new development on September 11, former federal minister Muhammad Ali Durrani has reportedly proposed the creation of three new provinces: Bahawalpur, South Punjab, and Hazara.

His speech adds specific proposals to the ongoing national debate on forming new administrative units in Pakistan.

The national conversation on creating new provinces has expanded to include a security dimension, with some linking new administrative units to the potential to curb terrorism. Meanwhile, government representative Tariq Fazal Chaudhry has also issued a statement on the administration's readiness to consider the creation of new provinces.

The national debate on creating new provinces has intensified with reports of public support from various regions. Residents in southern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and the city of Faisalabad have reportedly backed the formation of new administrative units. Meanwhile, a survey report has been released detailing public opinion on the matter. In Sindh, provincial minister Saeed Ghani has weighed in on the discussion, commenting on perceived obstacles to creating a new province in the region.

Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah has firmly rejected any proposal for the division of Sindh, stating that the idea has already been dismissed. His comments on September 11 reinforce his stance amid the ongoing national debate about creating new administrative units in Pakistan.

Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah has weighed in on the debate, stating that there cannot be "two systems" in the country. Speaking on the issue of provincial boundaries, he clarified his stance amid the ongoing discussions about creating new provinces. He also commented on the National Finance Commission (NFC) agreement in relation to the matter. Pakistan News will update this story as more confirmed details become available.

The government has announced that a parliamentary debate on the creation of new provinces will be held in October.

PPP leader Qamar Zaman Kaira has weighed in on the ongoing debate about creating new provinces, stating that any decision regarding Sindh will be made by its people.

The political discourse surrounding the creation of new provinces has intensified with prominent figures adding their voices to the debate. Rana Sanaullah has publicly stated that there should be a formal debate in Parliament on the matter.

Separately, Muhammad Ali Durrani adopted a firm stance, asserting that no political party, including the PPP, can oppose the formation of new provinces. He further escalated the rhetoric by referencing Article 6 of the Constitution in this context.

The debate over creating new provinces is set to be formally taken up in Parliament, with the government planning to place the matter on the agenda for the National Assembly and Senate sessions in October, according to Dr. Tariq Fazal Chaudhry.

This development comes as political discussions intensify, with some reports suggesting the possibility of a referendum on the issue. Available commentary indicates that the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) may oppose such a move.

The debate surrounding the creation of new provinces in Pakistan has reportedly intensified, with a particular focus on the Punjab government's potential plans. The discussion has also drawn comparisons with India, which has significantly increased its number of states over the years to manage its administration.

Sources and updates

Pakistan Observer

Sindh’s resistance to new provinces

Ayaz Ali Sheikh THE question of creating new provinces in Pakistan is becoming increasingly controversial over time. In Sindh, in…

Pakistan Observer

The elitist state

SINCE Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi claimed that the state system has collapsed, the debate over creating new administrative units…

Responses

>